Which Makeup Makes Maggie Gyllenhaal's Look Best?

I spy two very similar looks for Miss Maggie Gyllenhaal . . . I almost wanted to get out my pen and play spot the differences! In a period of about two weeks' time, the actress wore this identical frock but switched it up beauty-wise. Since the clothing's not an issue (and the hair's pretty close as well), let's compare face-to-face. Tell me, do you prefer her more bronzed look and heavier liner on the left or the brighter lips and paler face of the right?